Thursday, October 8, 2009

Aura and Authenticity in the Blair Witch Project

The 1999 faux-documentary The Blair Witch Project achieves its power though one all-important farce; that its audience believes – or can be persuaded to believe – that the film is ‘real’. This fascination with film mimicking life can be traced to many human art forms and the subjectiveness of that ‘reality’ is something that theorists continue to struggle with. In his essay The Work of Art in the Age of Mechanical Reproduction Walter Benjamin claims “...for the first time – and this is the effect of the film – man has to operate with his whole living person, yet forgoing its aura. For aura is tied to his presence; there can be no replica of it. The aura which, on the stage, emanates from Macbeth, cannot be separated for the spectators from that of the actor. However, the singularity of the shot in the studio is that the camera is substituted for the public. Consequently, the aura that envelops the actor vanishes, and with it the aura of the figure he portrays.” Here, the word aura can be interpreted to have a variety of meanings, one of which might be the moment’s potential spontaneity. Though the play Macbeth has been around for hundreds of years, each new actor will add something and each performance has the potential for surprise. Once something is a movie, however, it becomes solid. No matter how many times someone watches, it remains static; the aura of an instant’s ‘originality’ robbed. The Blair Witch Project attempts to regain this aura by presenting the work as fact. If an audience can accept the film as such, they can perceive it not as timeless, but as a salient moment trapped in time. The difference being the first can be viewed whenever at no expense to the movie’s meaning, whereas the second – a newly released news reel – would change the way we view the world now. We might perceive it to have an aura because (though mass produced) it can be placed in the immediate present, and so transforms our understanding of the universe that nothing after it can be the same. If The Blair Witch Project were, in fact, a documentary, Benjamin might be willing to argue its case. As it is not, we must conclude that it is only a failed attempt whose own nature forces it to fall short. The Blair Witch Project cannot have an aura as Benjamin would describe it, but mimics one skillfully enough to delude its audience – however briefly – into the illusion.

Further examining the 1999 film through the lens of Benjamin’s essay, we might look to how he compares magician with surgeon, saying that in art, painters are the former and magicians the latter. He claims, “The painter maintains in his work a natural distance from reality, the cameraman penetrates deeply into its web. There is a tremendous difference between the pictures they obtain. That of the painter is a total one, that of the cameraman consists of multiple fragments which are assembled under a new law. Thus, for contemporary man the representation of reality by the film is incomparably more significant than that of the painter, since it offers, precisely because of the thoroughgoing permeation of reality with mechanical equipment, an aspect of reality which is free of all equipment. And that is what one is entitled to ask from a work of art.” The Blair Witch Project is then entirely this highest form of art. Firstly, its medium is film and so it is inexplicably ‘true’ to reality in a way that even – say animated film – couldn’t be. Secondly, its fragmented presentation of reality allows for a sensation of near-entire “loss of equipment”. Because the clips are not complete, because the events are presented as real, because the characters themselves view life through the camera lens the viewer is asked – even more so than in a seamlessly cut film – to disengage and believe in the movie’s reality. Unlike in the matter of aura, the The Blair Witch Project’s falseness doesn’t disturb this effect. In fact, if anything, the fact that the “Project” isn’t real further compliments the piece as mechanically admirable art.

Though The Blair Witch Project may fail in its attempt to cut into Benjamin’s conception of aura – a blame which falls on form and fact, rather than execution – it does live up to his standards of modern, mechanized art in its innovative and engaging presentation.

Thursday, October 1, 2009

And They Lived (Circle All That Apply: After, Ever, Happily, N/A)

Anyone who has specialized in anything presented in a Hollywood film has probably complained about it at one time or another; whether the subject be science, medicine, history, or something else entirely. In my own experience, it was my fencing club, which spent several hours a week cringing over the blunders of Luke Skywalker, Inigo Montoya, and the ensemble cast of the Three Musketeers. However we may enjoy poking fun, however, the fact remains: that there is a greater demand for mass produced L.A. blockbusters than the “realism” found in such films as Yasujiro Ozu’s 1953 Tokyo Story.

And most who'd compare Tokyo Story with Hollywood Cinema would agree: the film is more real - that is, it better fits the Webster's definition of

re·al·ism
Pronunciation: \ˈrē-ə-ˌli-zəm\
Function: noun
Date: 1817

1 : concern for fact or reality and rejection of the impractical and visionary


There are no explosions. There are no grand plots and coincidences. The characters are neither superhuman nor uniquely special. Instead, the film follows an old couple going to visit their children in a post-Hiroshima Tokyo. Their trip is not fraught by grand plot devices, but only their offsprings' busy schedules and occasionally careless attitude. The purported authenticity of the tale is drawn from the sheer normalcy of its situation. Even the media's way of presenting the events enforces "real-world" drudgery: long shots that drag into boredom, cuts that are little more than meaningless changes of scene, and simple, true-to-life sets. Tokyo Story's "truth" derives from the fact that its mundane circumstances and cast force the viewer to relate to them as people and family, since they may not engage with them as dramatic heroes.

In contrast, classical Hollywood continuity film is deeply invested in hyperbolic serendipity. There is little "realism" as Tokyo Story would define it. In Hollywood, all main characters have goals, the sets - and even clothing! - carry metaphor, everyone is a wit, and everything has a purpose. Compared to the uncertain meanderings of Yasujiro Ozu’s movie, at first glance, it might seem that the word "realism" has no part in Hollywood films. When scrutinized, however, a new facet can be seen: that at the core of all good Blockbuster films - like hope at the bottom of Pandora's box - is a grain of truth that allows audiences to connect. While cinematic protagonists may surpass authentic probability, they do so with dreams that reflect ours, problems that hit home, and with the success or grace their viewers so desperately desire for their own lives. Classic continuity films cut seamlessly, letting people know only what they need to. It is a practice that any human - when seeking to recount events to a friend - does unconsciously. When we as a species tell stories, we leave out the descriptions of sleep, food, and bathroom breaks. We tell what is salient. We tell what is interesting. Most of us exaggerate.

In the writings of Plato, he presents the idea that all objects are merely a poor imitation of one pure, metaphysical conception of those objects. Using this philosophy, the realism of Tokyo Story can be compared with the actuality of a physical chair (that is, it reflects life with its boredom and flaws), while classical Hollywood movies endeavor to be closer to what their stories would, in a perfect world, be. In this light, there is no true "realism", but only preference and perspective.

Friday, September 25, 2009

Presidential Reflections

When the grainy, opening sequence of Bruce Conner’s Report rolls onto screen, the audience is already bracing for what it knows is about to happen. The footage preceding the assassination of president Kennedy is famous enough to set a dark tone even before anything has been said. The repetitive cuts settle the viewer deeper into their unease. Audio and image work hand in hand as the one provides a steady narration that regresses its audience back to that period in history and the other’s choppy surrealism sews sensations of horror. The first half of the film is homage and mourning; when the president’s wound is called out, and the visual turns a plain, strobing white, we are left to feel the moment’s dismay. While the announcer’s voice becomes shocked and breathless, the visuals match, throwing the audience into numb grief.

The fact that we, the viewers, cannot see the violence, cannot see if the president has survived – never mind that we know he has not – adds an almost Greek terror to the film; the panic that comes from things unseen. We are left in a state of agitated alarm, and when a countdown begins and time progresses back into random clips of separate violence, we are primed for it. Specifically, we are to lament Kennedy’s death, but later, the film presents us with the nature of death itself. Human works, such as silly commercials and bullfights, are shown as gratuitous and pointless. Clips of patriotic flags must contend with images of man’s subjugation of nature. Though the pall of the assassination is still upon us, Report presents death and pain as subjects of our own design. It seems to put the assassination's blame upon us as a species, forcing us to view the lesser parts of our nature. The frivolousness of the Kennedies seems to come through as the announcer talks of Jackie’s clothing choices and roses, as well as the size and grandeur of Airforce one and its crowds. In the middle of the film, it seems Report is not a piece of mourning at all, but a critique. A mad scientist raises Frankenstein, paralleling Kennedy’s coffin; it suggests our own inability to face death. Things change again, however, as the footage comes to a close. Tragedy takes center stage once more as the announcer foreshadows: “this is one of those impromptu moments for which President Kennedy is so well known. So many times you have heard that the secret service men find themselves without the president, that suddenly he has left them….” The visuals show various scenes in reverse, a sort of backward motion that offers forgiveness as the clips revert back to the positive.

Undoubtably, Report is meant to incite mourning; forcing its audience to live out the past, place it in context and compare it with both the present and our morals. It gives us the choppy, unmediated chaos of the living moment, and while our guard is down, asks us to question not just the “Report’s” instance, but those social factors which culminated in it happening.

Media and Content: Comparing Practices of Looking and Film Art

Looking at Robert Frank’s famous photo “Charleston”, the viewer is struck by several things simultaneously. First, most likely, is the visual; a striking black and white portrait of black and white people. From there, they might wonder contemplate the picture’s medium, or perhaps diverge, and focus instead on its subject. The two books Practices of Looking and Film Art share such a divergence.

The first seeks to pick apart the image as a piece of media. It would note that the photo is black and white, and that due to the style of dress, it was probably taken in the 1950’s, when color film was still hugely expensive. In its process, it would guess that the photographer stood beside the dark woman, on an open street during the day, and flush against a series of buildings. Phenomenologicaly, it would want to comment on the fact that the photo is a photo, not anything else, and as such can affect the viewer uniquely. It might argue that the piece is digital and seen on a screen, so onlookers can get a more intimate experience of it. It would want to note that since this piece can be reproduced with no loss in originality, it’s purpose can be skewed to fit political ends. Thus it can be said that Practices of Looking concerns itself with context, not content.

Film Art, on the other hand, would take the same picture and interpret in a new light; one of narrative. Like the media-centric Practices of Looking, Film Art would want to note that “Charleston” is from the 1950’s, but it would make this observation so that it might also draw a plot and story around that. Putting he photo in the 1950’s means that the Civil Rights movement is taking place, and the title indicates the setting is in the south. Ideas of racism and inequality spring to mind. The viewer looks at the juxtaposition of the white and black child and woman and can piece together a tale. Most likely the woman is a nanny for a rich white family. The child’s haughty expression and the woman’s long tried one become features to consider as plot. Film Art would have its readers question where this woman is going and what her situation is; it wants to know the tale behind the single, potent image.

Both books look to extract meaning from art, and the truths of both are valid. Practices of Looking would have us satiate our visual sensibilities. It would give meaning to the collection of granulated pixels without removing them from their form. Film Art however, calls upon that quote by Michael Shermer: that humans are “pattern seeking, story telling animals.” It seeks to vindicate our understanding of art through our own predilection for the narrative. By combining the wisdom of both, we can then grasp “Charleston” with a more critical understanding; that it is a picture about America, segregation, and inequality, in a medium meant for intimate exposure, in a format whose value comes from its reproducibility and ability to make a political statement.